The status of reflection in virtue epistemology

Kelp, C. (2019) The status of reflection in virtue epistemology. In: Silva Filho, W. J. and Tateo, L. (eds.) Thinking About Oneself: the Place and Value of Reflection in Philosophy and Psychology. Series: Philosophical studies series (141). Springer, pp. 33-43. ISBN 9783030182656 (doi: 10.1007/978-3-030-18266-3_3)

[img] Text
183107.pdf - Accepted Version

251kB

Publisher's URL: https://www.springer.com/gb/book/9783030182656

Abstract

This chapter claims that the main normative thesis of Sosa (that the ultimately desirable status for performances in general is the full aptness) can be subject of the objection of overintellectualisation of epistemic processes. It is proposed a way to safeguard Sosa’s perspective from this objection: to replace the Normative Thesis (NT), expressing the idea of full aptness, with the thesis that the ultimately desirable state of performances in general is the Simple Normative Thesis (SNT), stating that the fully desirable status for performances in general is (simple firstorder) aptness. With the rise of externalism, reflection’s central status in epistemology has come under threat: key epistemic phenomena such as knowledge and justified belief are no longer widely taken to essentially involve reflection. One notable exception to this trend is Sosa who, surprisingly enough, is a card-carrying externalist. Sosa develops a kind of virtue epistemology that promises to rehabilitate the status of reflection in epistemology. In this paper, I argue that Sosa remains ultimately unsuccessful in this regard. The thesis that is key to Sosa’s rehabilitation of reflection succumbs to exactly the kind of problem that dislodged reflection from its throne in epistemology. I then develop an alternative on behalf of Sosa. While the alternative view does avoid the problem Sosa encounters, it will not serve to rehabilitate the status of reflection. As virtue epistemologists, then, we will do well to continue to think of reflection has having been dislodged from its throne in epistemology.

Item Type:Book Sections
Status:Published
Glasgow Author(s) Enlighten ID:Kelp, Professor Christoph
Authors: Kelp, C.
College/School:College of Arts & Humanities > School of Humanities > Philosophy
Publisher:Springer
ISBN:9783030182656
Published Online:29 May 2019
Copyright Holders:Copyright © 2019 Springer Nature Switzerland AG
First Published:First published in Thinking About Oneself: the Place and Value of Reflection in Philosophy and Psychology: 33-43
Publisher Policy:Reproduced in accordance with the publisher copyright policy
Related URLs:

University Staff: Request a correction | Enlighten Editors: Update this record